The distinction, perhaps, lies in humor and self-awareness. The great Nut Jobs Author usually retains a sliver of the trickster. They know, on some level, that they are performing madness. Burroughs was grimly funny. Pynchon hides from cameras. Even Pound, in his later years, recanted his fascism. The dangerous nut job has no humor. The great nut job is a court jester with a knife.
This author started writing a memoir. Halfway through, the “I” fragmented. Reality slipped. The Confessional Collapser cannot distinguish between what happened to them and what they dreamt happened. The result is a work like Blood and Guts in High School , where the author becomes a character who becomes a prostitute who becomes a Persian slave girl, all while rewriting Nathaniel Hawthorne. Or, more tragically, the works of John Kennedy Toole , whose A Confederacy of Dunces is so perfectly, painfully a product of its author’s isolation and paranoia that Toole killed himself before it won the Pulitzer. The nut jobbery here is not malice; it is a permeability of the skin between self and fiction. nut jobs author
But without them, we’d only have books that make sense. And who wants to live in a world that makes sense? J. S. Latham is a critic and recovering literary journalist. He owns a first edition of “The Atrocity Exhibition” and is currently 400 pages into a self-published novel about time-traveling bees. The distinction, perhaps, lies in humor and self-awareness